Rick Astley & Nirvana? Never Gonna Give Your Teen Spirit Up? Oh well…

• Absolutely! X-Factor is WAY more fun. Plus, American Idol isn't the same without Simon! Randy, Jennifer Lopez and Steven Tyler are too nice and boring.
• No way! American Idol is still way better even thought they are both similar!
• You kidding? I'm watching both! I'll have my cake and eat it too!

View Results